I once had an abrasive, nasty little student tell me that comparing modern America to the Roman Empire was “propaganda promulgated by a liberal academic elite.” By merely asking the question, she assured me, I was part of the problem. When I gave her a C for a final grade she told the Dean that I had a small arsenal stashed away in my apartment and was planning to murder half the student body. Then she vanished off the face of the globe. Of course, that’s neither here nor there.
Although she was obviously unstable and her reasoning was completely wrong she did have a point: comparing America to the Roman Empire didn’t work. The old doctrine of unlimited expansion may have been applicable to the United States a hundred years ago, but today it seemed worn. Sure there are parallels, especially culturally, and some comparison is justified, even worthwhile, but the politically/militarily, we diverge.
This weekend NATO comes to Chicago. One of the perks (if you like traffic jams, terrorist threats and protestors) of being the President’s hometown.
The North Atlantic Treaty Organization. Founded in 1949 as a mutual defense pact against Soviet Communism. Galvanized by the Korean conflict and stiffened by a hundred regional wars over the last sixty years, today the combined military spending of NATO accounts for over 70% of all that on the globe. Some have called it the most successful military alliance in human history, others have called it the modern Delian League, the United States at its center.
America as Athens. Headstrong, stubborn, arrogant. A pack of hypocrites, brilliant, boastful and flawed. With the defeat of Persia, Athens rose to command the Mediterranean through a political-military alliance designed, ostensibly, to counter any Persian threat. In reality, Athens used its defense network as an apparatus of control. A funnel for cash and regional influence that ultimately led to abuse, war and collapse.
Even here the parallels aren’t exact. America carries most of the NATO burden. Many in the U.S. are calling for the alliance to be disbanded. Nothing comparable to a Spartan or Persian threat exists.
Still, it’s an interesting idea.
Europeans complain about American militarism constantly, but what they don’t like to admit is that the American military keeps them safe and free to spend their hard earned Euros on things like universal healthcare and government pension plans. In light of the financial crisis now deconstructing the Eurozone they need us even more than ever. America is very much the protector of the old world and for that we can make them pay.
So maybe there is a bit of that Athenian imperialism alive and well in American exceptionalism. Maybe we’re not that far removed from the Delian League. Let’s only hope that by the end our paths diverge.




